April 6, 2007
After only two months of blogging, one of the best things I’ve noticed is how sharing and supportive most bloggers are. They’re eager to help others get noticed and read through tipping, links and kind references. There seems to be very little ego in the marketing blogosphere.
So it doesn’t surprise me that Drew, on getting his 1,000th comment at Drew’s Marketing Minute, would invite the author of that comment to write a guest post. What a wonderful and generous way to mark a milestone. And how fortunate for me that the 1,000th comment happened to be mine.
Drew’s invitation is typical of the sharing mindset that is pervasive throughout the marketing blogosphere. I think it’s a major reason so many of us become active bloggers.
But what do you do when someone asks you to share information when it’s for their commercial gain?
As blogs are becoming recognized by marketers as an important form of social media that can influence and motivate, public relations and advertising agencies are starting to pitch bloggers, in hopes of gaining write-ups about their clients’ products and services. Since blogs are such personal forms of mass communications, marketers realize they can be powerful persuaders.
In the past several days, I received my first two pitches from PR people. Each represents a different end of the spectrum of professionalism.
My first pitch came from Harley Jebens at Click Here, a Dallas interactive marketing agency where our blogging friend Cam Beck works. Harley’s email to me was simple, straightforward and professional – he identified himself and his agency and said he was attaching information on a campaign my readers might find of interest. No hype – no obnoxious push. A news release and website were attached, if I wanted more info, along with a promise to answer any questions if I gave him a call or email.
Although I have no interest in talking about The MySpace page for the Travelocity Roaming Gnome it was a professional pitch and my compliments to Harley for a good try.
The second pitch came from a book publisher’s PR department. It was an email full of hyperbole about a book unrelated to anything I write about. In the email, the publicist tells me (not asks) that it’s something my readers will want to know about. How could she know that if, obviously, she hadn’t done her homework by looking at my blog. It wasn’t even addressed to me by name; it said Dear Blogger. The pitch told me where to buy the book. (You want me to write about your product and you won’t send or offer to send me a review copy? Thanks a lot.)
In the 30 years I’ve been doing public relations at agencies large and small, including my own firm for the past 15, I’ve learned what works and what doesn’t. The second pitch method does not work. It wouldn’t work if I were pitching a writer at a newspaper or magazine, and it won’t work to get into a blog.
I approached several bloggers on a client’s behalf for the first time back in January. After researching to find blogs on parenting, I viewed as many as I could, to get an idea of what they write about. I emailed the authors, with an approach similar to what Harley did when he pitched me – honest, transparent, not pushy.
The response was encouraging. Most responded by asking questions and/or asking to talk with my client before they told their readers about the product. Some took me up on my offer to send a product sample. One blogger asked me to have my client post a comment on her blog, talking about the product. A few didn’t respond and probably chose not to talk about the item. Overall, the client got some positive reviews and spirited discussion of the product’s merits in comments.
Key is that the approach was done gently and professionally, with full disclosure and no deception or trickery. No attempt to sneak onto a blog by posting a "sell" as a comment, as I saw tried just this week on two blogs. (One of the bloggers was annoyed and quickly deleted the comment. Lucky for the offending PR person that he didn’t choose instead to blast the product being pitched.)
You may have already been pitched by a PR person. If not, I bet you will in the coming year as the PR profession discovers the blogosphere. How bloggers are treated by marketers and their public relations representatives seeking to use their channels of communication will make a difference, since, ultimately, the decision will be yours as to what you care to share with your readers.
How would you prefer to be pitched?
~ David Reich, My 2 Cents
More
To which I said…“You are very right. Let’s do it. Watch for an e-mail from me!”
Two weeks later — here we are. And we’d like you to consider joining us.
And out of that blogging conversation and a few e-mails, Gavin & I concocted the idea for an e-book about this new era of communications we’ve all entered together. But not just any book. It has to be a quick book. Exciting. Sharp. Inclusive. It had to be a book about community and conversation that came from that community and spoke the same vernacular. The title — The Conversation Age.
And that is why we are talking to you. Our idea:
If you’d like to write a chapter, here’s what you need to do. E-mail me with a commitment and a focus/topic that will fit under Conversation Age (first in gets to choose) by April 11th. I’m going to keep the master list so we keep the content from getting too overlapped.
Your chapter will be due April 30th.
We’ve already got a few chapter authors on board. Want to know who your co-authors will be? (If I missed anyone — I apologize. Shoot me an e-mail.)
Gavin Heaton
Drew McLellan
CK
Valeria Maltoni
Emily Reed
Katie Chatfield
Greg Verdino
Mack Collier
Lewis Green
Sacrum
Ann Handley
Paul McEnany
Roger von Oech
Anna Farmery
David Armano
Bob Glaza
Mark Goren
Matt Dickman
Scott Monty
Richard Huntington
We hope you’ll join us! And a special thanks to Mike Sansone for creating our button for us!
UPDATE: Ann asks a great question. Who is our audience? Our intended audience is anyone who has to create marketing tools in this Conversation Age. It might be a small business owner, a CMO, a marketing student, an agency type, a marketing blogger, or even a professor who is teaching tomorrow’s marketers.
UPDATE 2: We were waiting until CK was back online to make this announcement. As most of you probably know, she lost her mom recently. Gavin and I decided that one way this community could honor our friend CK and her mom was to dedicate the book to her. What I said to CK in an e-mail was “as you can imagine…many of your friends have already signed-on to write a chapter. So it felt right to make this community and conversation-focused book be dedicated to the woman who obviously taught you your values of community, listening, loving and bringing others into the conversations.”
And so it will be. We hope that makes this project even more special to all the authors, readers and of course, our friend CK.
UPDATE 3: The book is CLOSED! We have exceeded our 100 author goal — thank you very much. We are now a mere 17 days away from the chapter submission deadline, so we will not be accepting any new authors. Stay tuned for the author list — it rocks!